THOUGHTS

Monuments’ Removal Priceless

By Jeff Thomas

When news broke that the city spent over $2 million to remove the Confederate monuments at the same time that we learned that New Orleans had the one of the most violent weekends ever, my email box was flooded with those asking whether that money could have been better spent fighting crime.  Not just NO but HELL NO was my swift and stern response.

For the first time in a long time New Orleans is leading the country in progressive actions.  From St. Louis to Baltimore to Georgia and Tennessee, municipalities are starting to remove Confederate monuments. Remember those Mastercard priceless commercials?  Tickets to the game $150.  Two hot dogs and sodas $50.  Spending time bonding with your son- Priceless

Priceless Scenarios

Well……Cost of confederate statues remaining in place. Damaged psyche of hundreds of thousands of people.  Cost of honoring traitors and combatants for slavery’s preservation Misinformation and distorted reality.  Cost of removing the confederate statues –Priceless.

Cost of confederate statues remaining in place – Happy unpressured racists.  Cost of city spending tax dollars collected from millions of African Americans and informed Whites to maintain statues over the last 100 years- @ $20 million.  Cost of removing the confederate statues. Priceless. 

Cost of confederate statues remaining in place- Agitated African American and informed White activist class Cost of Ignoring reality of meaning for erection of states. A shadowy future for all New Orleanians Cost of removing the confederate statues Priceless

Many and more illustrative scenarios exist.  The point is that those bellyaching about the cost of removal of those Confederate monument deny the reality of history and only seek to preserve the societal advantages bestowed upon those who profited from slavery.  Whilst most white New Orleanians are not the blatant confederate flag waving racists who caused the price of the monuments removal to escalate by a million dollars, many would prefer to have seen the monuments remain and the money invested in crime fighting.

Crime Fighting is Racist Code for Arresting Blacks

Crime fighting in America traces its origins to slave catching.  The original police were hired to control the movement of African Americans around the South.  The biggest expense racist plantation owners faced was the cost of the runaway.  And runaway slaves were a constant and persistent issue as black men and women fled with such regularity that plantation owners hired young white men and paid hefty sums for the return of those slaves who had run away.  These men were the first police officers in America.

Modern crime fighting is based upon this principle.  The control of the movement of African American men in society to the benefit of white Americans via jobs and increased profits.  300 years ago this meant jobs as police officers for young poor and unskilled white men and the unpaid labor of young African American men for the economic benefit of white plantation owners across the South.  Today this still means jobs as police officers for young poor unskilled white men and the forced labor of African American men in prisons to the economic benefit of white contract holders across the country.

Crime in New Orleans is a Real Problem

The great failure of modern society is the continuation of the race based approach to crime.  Crime is a result of poverty, lack of jobs, bad schools, substandard housing and the over policing of the African American community. Combine the over representation by the media of the criminality of African American males (you are aware that more white men commit crimes than African American men), and it’s easy to see why many think putting black men in jail is a real solution. But the very foundation of American wealth for whites is the myth of a sub human and prone to criminal behavior black man as justification by whites for self-aggrandizement and financial exploitation.  Today’s simple minded Louisianans maintain the country’s highest rates of incarceration at the expense of public safety.

Crime fighting should mean barrier removals.  Invest in good paying jobs, better housing, better education, reduced or eliminated fines and fees, no incarceration for nonviolent offenses,  no car booting and fewer police in poor neighborhoods escalating encounters with citizens.  An investment in the African American families would eliminate more crime than adding another 500 police officers.   Instead, we have Lost Cause advocates rallying their troops around this antiquated notion of “crime fighting”.

So when I get emails asking if the money spent on removing the monuments would be better spent on fighting crime in New Orleans, I reply HELL NO.